Which Water Purification Systems Are Best? - A Comparison Of The Three Most Common Technologies

water is essential to our health and comfort. Not onlyReverse osmosis, also known as hyperfiltration or
do we rely on it to stay hydrated, we use it in manyultra-filtration, was developed with U.S. government
other ways including bathing, cleaning and cookingfunding as a means of desalinating ocean water. A
food, and laundering our clothes. Fresh water has longreverse osmosis water purifier uses a
been a concern of both public communities andsemi-permeable membrane that allows pure water to
private individuals, and several different waterpass through it, while contaminants are trapped by
purification systems and treatment technologies havethe tiny pores in the membrane.
been developed to help ensure that tap water isThe process requires that the water be pressurized
safe for human consumption. But how do theseto help force it through the membrane. Most
different technologies compare?standard residential water systems have sufficient
Whether you get your water from a well or a citypressure. Like activated carbon filters, reverse
system, water sources can become contaminated byosmosis also uses charged particles to help filter out
bacteria, runoff, and improper treatment. Even ifimpurities.
water isn’t contaminated, it may contain ironThe effectiveness of a reverse osmosis water
and other hard minerals that cause discoloration andpurifier depends on the density of the membrane. A
can build up in the body, or chlorine that leaves anmembrane with larger pores will obviously let larger
unpleasant odor and taste. Consequently, manyimpurities pass through. It is also important that the
people choose to treat or filter their water tomembrane be cleaned regularly for proper functioning.
improve flavor and protect against contaminants.Higher quality reverse osmosis water filters use a
Chlorine is commonly used by municipal waterprocess known as crossflow to allow the membrane
treatment plants and is effective in killing manyto continually clean itself. Crossflow directs some of
different bacteria. However, it is not effective againstthe water downstream from the membrane,
some organisms such as Cryposporidium and Giardia.sweeping the rejected contaminants away so they
Both of these organisms can be found in lakes,do not build up and block the membrane.
rivers, and ground water and can cause seriousThere are two types of membranes commonly used
intestinal illness.in reverse osmosis water filters --Thin Film Composite
As mentioned, many people feel that chlorine leaves(TFC) and Cellulose Triacetate (CTA). TFC
an unpleasant taste and smell. In addition, there havemembranes are noticeably more effective the CTA
been numerous cases where the city water supplymembranes but they tend to be less resistant to the
became contaminated despite the fact that it wasdeteriorating effects of chlorine. This problem can be
treated. People with city water supplies often useavoided by using an activated carbon pre-filter to
other water purifiers and home water filters toremove the chlorine first.
ensure that their water is pure and tastes good. TheReverse osmosis water purifiers come in different
three most common options are carbon filters,sizes and styles including countertop and whole house
reverse osmosis water filters, and ultraviolet lightwater purification systems. They are capable of
water purification.filtering out a long list of contaminants including:
Each of these technologies uses a different approach• chlorine and other treatment related
to treat water, and they each have different levelsproducts
of effectiveness against various contaminants. One• bacteria
may work well to remove chemicals but be• salts, sugars, proteins
completely ineffective against bacteria, and vice• dyes
versa.• heavy metals
In reality, there is no single filter or treatment thatOne drawback of reverse osmosis water filters is
will eliminate every contaminant from your water.that they are more expensive than carbon filter
The best approach is to have your water tested fortreatment systems, with the average home system
contaminants and then purchase a home watercosting around $300. Also, the purification process is
purifier that guards against the particularusually somewhat slow due to the use of pressurized
contaminants that cause you concern.water. It can take an entire day to produce 15
Another option is to combine treatment technologies.gallons of purified water. And a typical reverse
Most higher-end systems use a combination ofosmosis water purifier may need up to 8 gallons of
carbon filters and one of the other treatmentuntreated water to generate a single gallon of
technologies to achieve the best results. Let’spurified water.
look at the different technologies to see where eachUV Water Purification
is effective.As the name implies, ultraviolet light water purification
Carbon Filterssystems use ultraviolet (UV) light to treat water and
Carbon is one of the most powerful absorbentsrender microorganisms harmless. The UV light comes
available and it has been used for many years as afrom a high intensity lamp that is usually enclosed in a
means of removing impurities. The absorbing powersprotective quartz sleeve. When water passes
of carbon can be further enhanced by adding athrough the water treatment system, the UV light
slightly positive electrical charge. This is known asdamages the structure of any organisms and makes
activated carbon, and it is used in many standardthem sterile.
home water filters. As the water passes over theAlthough a UV water purifier requires electricity to
positively charged carbon, the negative ions of theoperate, it draws about the same amount of energy
contaminants are drawn to the surface of the carbonas a light bulb. However, the lamp bulb itself needs to
granules and removed from the water.be replaced every year to ensure adequate intensity.
Activated carbon filters typically use granularWhile whole house UV water purification systems are
activated carbon (GAC) or powdered block carbon.effective on most bacteria, viruses, molds, algae and
Both work well for filtering and purifying but carbonother organisms, they do not remove chlorine, heavy
block filters have been shown to remove moremetals, VOCs, or other chemicals. And countertop
contaminants. Either type of activated carbon filtersUV systems, which expose the water to UV lighting
help reduce or remove a wide variety offor less time, do not always remove all organisms.
contaminants, including:UV water purifiers average around $700 for a whole
• volatile organic chemicals (VOCs)house system, making them more expensive initially
• pesticides and herbicidesthan other types of treatments. In addition, without
• chlorine, radon, and other chemicals oftena pre-filter system, contaminants can build up and
found in tap water.reduce the intensity of the UV lamp. For these
All of this protection comes in a relatively inexpensivereasons, many people combine UV water purification
package. You can purchase carbon filter systemssystems with carbon filters, which also increases the
that fit on your faucet for about $30, or you cancosts.
choose a whole house water purification system thatAs you can see, each of the three common water
utilizes carbon filter technology for around $100.treatment technologies has its advantages and
However, unless they are densely compacted, mostdrawbacks. Deciding which is best depends on your
carbon block filters are not effective at removingbudget and the type of water contaminants you
heavy metals or bacteria. For this reason, manywant to remove or prevent. A test of your tap
people consider combining carbon filters with one ofwater will help you determine the appropriate water
the other types of water purification systems.filtration system for your needs.
Reverse Osmosis Water Filters